Dear Eddie: What Else He Left Behind
Part 3 of 3 in the San Miguel papers. The man behind the fight, told by the documents he kept.
Every trilogy owes its audience an ending. This is mine.
Think of the very first Star Wars trilogy. Part 1 was the end of the story: a 1983 newspaper front page reporting how the great San Miguel fight was settled. Part 2 went back and showed how that ending came about, through a letter and a P.O. box. This one, Part 3, is Return of the Jedi. It's the episode where the son finally finds out who his father really was.
Unlike Luke, I won't need a lightsaber. Just patience, a magnifying glass, and a very old box. This last part is about the man who made it all happen. He was a quiet man. Try googling him. Eduardo "Eddie" Lichauco barely comes up, because almost everything he did happened before any of us were online. No website, no press release archive, no LinkedIn. Just paper.
So I've had to piece him together the analog way, from a box of old documents he kept from 1965 until the day he died in 1989, and I've uploaded every piece of paper mentioned on this blog to the carousel gallery at the end. (enjoy the read)
At the end of Part 2, I asked a question I couldn't leave alone: what else did he leave behind?
The answer was a folder. Then a booklet. Then a book with something brown spilled across three of its pages, which nobody had bothered to wipe. Inside were memos punched with two holes at the top and two more down the side, filed once in an office binder and again in a personal one. There were letters on letterhead that still listed cable codes for Western Union. And there was a newspaper clipping with its masthead cut out and pasted above it, the way people kept press files before anyone had heard of a scanner.
The first two parts told me what he did. This box tells me who he was before he did it.
So let's start at the beginning. He did.
A boy who chose the books
The oldest portrait of him in the box sits inside a book: pages 102 to 105 of an anthology of TOYM awardees, under the heading "Eduardo S. Lichauco '63 Banking."
For years I had filed his TOYM award under 1969. The book politely corrected me. The "'69" I half-remembered is bleeding through the paper from the facing page, and it belongs to someone else. My father won in 1963, for banking. He was 29.
The profile opens somewhere I didn't expect. He was born in Manila in 1934, one of six children of Luis Lichauco and Alicia Nieva, and by his own admission he "grew up easy-going and pampered." As a sophomore at the Ateneo, his one claim to fame was being team captain of the junior basketball team. His father, less impressed than the team, sat him down: "Make a choice, basketball or education?"

He chose school, which is the only reason this blog has anything to write about.
He graduated from Thomas Jefferson Preparatory School in St. Louis in 1951. Offered Cornell, his father's alma mater, or Harvard, he picked Harvard "simply to annoy my father." He majored in economics, made the dean's list, and graduated with honors in 1955. Then, having made his point, he went to Cornell anyway for an MBA.
In September 1958, he came home and eloped with Josefina "Josie" Trinidad, an old friend with a Master of Laws from Yale. My mother. She was, it seems, the one person in the story he didn't bother to annoy first.
Far East Bank, and a name to remember
His first employer was Far East Bank and Trust Company. Before long, they sent him to New York to train with the Trusts Division of Morgan Guaranty Trust Company and with Chemical Bank New York Trust Co.
Remember the name Morgan Guaranty. It comes back.
He returned in 1961 as assistant vice-president and trust officer, managing about ₱28 million of other people's money; that's a lot of money today. He also returned with what the profile calls an obsession: to build a proper investment management service, one that would "lend a certain degree of sobriety to an equities market that is predominantly speculative." Sobriety, in the Manila stock market of the 1960s. Ambitious.
Within two years he had built it anyway. By 1963 he was administering what the profile calls "the largest accumulation of pension trust funds in the country." His TOYM nominator put the stakes plainly: the comfort thousands of employees looked forward to in old age depended on "the responsibility that he has dared to assume."
He was 29. At 29, I was still deciding which pen to buy.

₱2,000 a month
The earliest paper in the folder runs four pages and is dated 15 December 1965. To: Eduardo S. Lichauco. From: Enrique Zobel. Subject: Your Transfer to ASC.
He had joined CCP Securities Corporation, Ayala's investment house, on August 23, 1965. From January 1, 1966, he would sit on the books of Ayala Securities Corporation as a Division Manager.
The terms follow, numbered like a contract. A monthly salary of ₱2,000. A guaranteed bonus of ₱18,000 a year. Twenty days' local leave. After three years in management, three months abroad with pay, plus "the equivalent of two tourist round-the-world plane passages." A ₱2,000 group life policy. A retirement gratuity of one month's pay for every year served. Then Item 5, delivered without a trace of apology: "The company grants no medical and hospital benefits to its senior executive personnel."
Round-the-world tickets, yes. A doctor, no. Priorities.

Every page carries his blue-ink initials in the margin. On the last page, faint beneath Zobel's looping signature, a second signature line shows through, with a typed name ending in "LICHAUCO." He signed to accept.
What strikes me isn't the money. It's the order. Every leave, every ticket, every contingency is spelled out, right down to how a partial month counts toward retirement. This is how Ayala handled its people in 1965: on paper, in numbered clauses, with copies to the file. I believe it still works that way.
One clause, though, matters more than the rest, and I wouldn't understand why for another eighteen years. He was to represent the Ayala companies on whatever boards he was sent to, and "any director's fees or remuneration" from those seats "shall be turned over to Ayala Securities Corporation."
In other words, the fees weren't his. He initialed that page too.

The coup
The next paper is a clipping from The Manila Chronicle, Friday, 10 December 1971. The kicker reads Financial 'Coup.' Below it, the headline: "Ayalas Take Over Control of Bank of PI."

The story describes "a five-year-long stock fight" between the Ayalas and the Archdiocese of Manila, which had long controlled the bank. By the end of September 1971, Ayala held 51 percent. And the very first offer, the article says, came in December 1967 "by Ayala's own investment bank, the CCP Securities."
CCP Securities. His house.
Years later, he told an Asiaweek columnist he was made president of Ayala Investment & Development Corporation, as CCP Securities was later renamed, two years after joining. That puts him at the head of the firm right around the time it made its first bid for the bank.
To be fair to the record, no paper in the box names him in the share campaign. But he was inside the firm that ran it; he kept the clipping, and within fifteen months he was sitting in the bank's executive suite. People rarely keep clippings of deals they had nothing to do with. I should know. I keep clippings for a living.
A second crack at life
The TOYM profile also holds a chapter we knew from our mother. We had heard the story at home, but never the details. Those were in the book all along.
"Four years ago, Eduardo S. Lichauco was dying." It began as an ache in his ears that spread through his head. One night he told my mother, "I have cancer." A Manila hospital confirmed it, and he flew to New York for cobalt treatment.

There, "not particularly religious," he prayed to St. Martin de Porres, his father's favorite saint. He kept the request businesslike: "I simply asked him to grant me a second crack at life, making no promises, no oaths." Even with a saint, he didn't overcommit.
After the first treatment, his tissue sample showed no trace of cancer. The doctors concluded Manila had misdiagnosed him. He concluded it was a miracle. Both parties, I suppose, went home satisfied.
He came back softer. "Before I got sick, I was what you would call addicted to perfection," he said. "I was often rough with my employees and peers." Afterward, he made friends with his subordinates. Even so, the profile ends with him restless, convinced he hadn't yet kept the promise he made himself: "to make himself a better man so as to influence others for the better."
The timing puts the illness around 1971, the same year Ayala took the bank.
Executive Vice President, at 39
By March 1973, he was Executive Vice President of the Bank of the Philippine Islands. A Business Day clipping from that month shows him lecturing graduate staff at the Center for Research and Communication on merchant banking, which he described as a bank that "performs the functions of all kinds of banking institutions." The Chronicle had named merchant banking as the whole point of buying BPI. Now he was the one explaining it in public.

The government's bank merger decree, PD 117, was barely six weeks old. The ink was still drying, and he was already teaching it.
"We have arrived"
Then comes the high point of the folder. It's a booklet with a speckled cover, five black bars on one side and five grey ones on the other, folding into each other like two banks becoming one. The title reads, "A merger to mark a new kind of banking in the Philippines." Someone wrote "1974" on the cover by hand; I recognize it as my Dad's handwriting.

Companies printed booklets like this for one reason. They wanted to say: we have arrived.
The center spread is dated 14 June 1974. Bank of the Philippine Islands, strong in the Visayas and Mindanao, had merged with Peoples Bank and Trust Company, strong in Luzon. The result was forty-eight branches, "the broadest branch network among all private commercial banks," with resources above ₱1.3 billion. The endorsements came from the President of the Philippines, the Central Bank governor, the SEC chairman and, of all people, the new Archbishop of Manila, whose predecessor had lost the bank to Ayala three years earlier. Gracious of him.

There was also a minority partner, holding 20 percent: Morgan Guaranty Trust Company of New York.
Yes, that Morgan Guaranty. The same one that had trained a young Far East Bank trust officer in New York fifteen years before.
Now look at the management panel at the bottom of the page. The top row holds three large portraits: A. F. de Villa-Abrille, President. Enrique Zobel, Chairman. Eduardo S. Lichauco, Executive Vice President. Ten vice presidents sit underneath, in smaller frames. He also appears on the thirteen-man Board of Directors and the five-man Executive Committee.
Two more faces from the 1965 memo also turn up. Gregorio Licaros, the CCP Securities chief my father once reported to, is now Governor of the Central Bank and endorses the merger. Salvador Lorayes, copied on that memo, now sits on the board. Nine years, and the same names keep passing the same papers around.

So did my father bring Morgan to the table? The booklet doesn't say. What it does show is that the bank Ayala bought needed a foreign partner, and one of the three men at the top had spent his early career inside that partner's trust division. I believe he was instrumental. The paper proves he was in the room.
On the right-hand page, someone ticked the heading "Merchant Banking" in pen. I'd bet on his hand.
At home, the booklet means something else. My mother told us 1974 was the year of the merger, and the year she was expecting their first girl after three boys. My father wanted to name her "Morgana."
They settled on "Michelle," which was a mercy, because, as we all know, Morgan le Fay in the Arthurian legend is King Arthur's half-sister, and she turns out to be a witch. Some deals are better left out of the birth certificate.
"I have been instructed"
Nine months after the merger, on 12 March 1975, he resigned as BPI's Executive Vice President. The letter runs three sentences, on letterhead that still reads "Pioneer Bank of the Orient," and the middle sentence does all the work: "I have been instructed to rejoin Ayala Corporation and assume a new assignment."

That isn't a departure. That's a recall. The group had sent him into the bank for the takeover and the merger, and it brought him home once both were done.
His new assignment was Vice President-Treasurer of Ayala Corporation, "in charge of coordinating and planning Ayala's expansion in the Philippines and Southeast Asia." He kept his BPI board seat and picked up a few more along the way: AIDC, FGU Insurance, Ayala Finance (Hong Kong) and China Underwriters. Board meetings, it seems, were his idea of a hobby.

"While age is still in my favor"
A year later, he left.
His letter to Zobel is dated March 16, 1976, and it opens with a summary of his working life: "During the last eighteen years, I have been fending for myself, first in Far East Bank and since 1965 in the service of Ayala. Now, my compelling objective is to secure the future of my four minor children, as well."

He wanted "to strike out on my own, and seek the limit of what I can do for my family." He didn't pretend it was safe. "But I am now 42, and as I must face this decision sooner or later, now is the appropriate time while age is still in my favor."
Zobel answered three days later. He accepted "with deep regret," and thanked my father for explaining his reasons in person, "aside from the letter." Then came a paragraph someone later bracketed in red pencil: should he start his own business and need minority investors, "let me know as we might be interested."
He signed off "Affectionately," and told my father to come to him "as a close friend."

That's not how you write to a departing employee. That's how you write to someone you fully intend to see again.
He went on his own and set up Asian Merchant Finance. Merchant banking, once more. Some men change careers. He just changed letterheads.
Back at Zobel's side
Seven years later, Zobel did see him again.
You know this part from Part 1, "The 43-Year-Old Receipt," and Part 2, "P.O. Box 259: The Prequel Was in the Mailbox." In January 1983, he wrote to the SEC "in my capacity as stockholder and director" of San Miguel Corporation, calling the board's blanket delegation of power to its chairman "illegal, immoral and potentially most prejudicial." UPI called him "a Zobel man on the board." By late February, Zobel had sold his stake and the fight was over.
Consider what that means. He didn't have the Ayala name. He had been out of the company for seven years. Yet when Zobel needed someone in the boardroom for the biggest corporate fight of the decade, he sent Eddie.
The family tells a story about that seat. My father took it in place of Zobel's son, Iñigo. Director's fees at San Miguel were not small change. By my father's own count, in that same letter to the SEC, each director drew over ₱600,000 a year. When the checks came, he kept a small cut for expenses, around 15 percent, and sent the rest to Iñigo with a note: "I'm just taking my fee; the rest goes back to you as they are rightfully yours."
For years I filed that under legend. I don't anymore. I have the receipts.
Read it next to the 1965 memo, and it stops being a story about generosity. Eighteen years earlier, he had initialed a clause saying fees from a seat held for someone else were not his to keep. In 1983, nobody was making him follow it. He followed it anyway. And this was the same man who, that very January, told the SEC it was immoral for directors to collect fees for responsibilities they had handed off. He was hardly going to pocket the fees for a seat he was keeping warm for someone else.
"Ayala had very strong shared values"
The last paper in the box arrived after he did not.
On 16 February 1990, twelve weeks after my father died at 55, Asiaweek columnist Hari Bedi published a piece called "The Problem With Poaching." He had interviewed my father not long before, and wrote that he "talked fondly of his long years with the Ayala Group." Then he quoted him:
"Ayala had very strong shared values. First, we had the heritage. The unifying element was extensive communication during my time. That's what made us strong. The officers would meet regularly, and each would talk about his important customers and how we could help." — Eduardo Lichauco, quoted by Hari Bedi, "The Problem With Poaching," Asiaweek, 16 Feb 1990, p. 72

Thirteen years after his resignation, he still said "we."
At the time, he was about to join Indonesia's Lippo Group as a strategic planner, and he was clear-eyed about what changing houses meant. "I am very mindful of my background in my future relations," he said. "That's why I say you have to grow your own talent." He had been raised at Ayala, and he knew it.
What the box taught me
I wrote about San Miguel because I found an old newspaper in my father's things, and this blog is all about the stories behind "old things." I wrote the prequel because of another old letter and a P.O. box. This last part came out of the same box, and it filled in a career I knew only in outline: Far East Bank, Ayala, BPI, Ayala again, out on his own, and back to Enrique Zobel. I could have recited that list. I couldn't have told you what any of it meant.
Here's the uncomfortable part. Growing up, I hardly knew my father. He and my mother separated in 1978, and most of what I knew about him came secondhand. The man in these papers I met decades after he was gone, one memo and one letter at a time.
So, what did they teach me?
First, that a career gets built in paper you'd never think to frame. A transfer memo. A three-sentence resignation. A booklet nobody reads twice. Put them in order, and they say more than any eulogy.
Second, that loyalty runs both ways, or it isn't loyalty. Zobel signed "Affectionately" to a man walking out the door, and seven years later trusted him with a boardroom.
Third, that you take what's yours and give back what isn't, even when nobody's counting. Especially then.
Fourth, that he left when age was still in his favor, and had the nerve to say so in writing.
And last, that a man who once called himself "addicted to perfection" spent his second chance trying, instead, to be a better one.
The back cover of the 1974 booklet carries the bank's seal and a single line: "the bank for the long run." My father didn't get the long run. His papers did, and they're still talking. Apparently he filed everything in duplicate for a reason.

We spend our days here on other people's old papers. This one, again, is my own.
Sources
From the box (family papers, author's collection)
Enrique Zobel to Eduardo S. Lichauco, memo, "Your Transfer to ASC," 15 December 1965, 4 pp., initialed and signed in conforme.
Perfecto C. Borja, "Ayalas Take Over Control of Bank of PI," The Manila Chronicle, 10 December 1971.
"Lichauco talks on merchant banking," Business Day, 13 March 1973.
Bank of P.I. and Peoples Bank, "A merger to mark a new kind of banking in the Philippines," merger booklet, center spread dated 14 June 1974.
"Eduardo S. Lichauco '63 Banking," TOYM anthology, pp. 102–105 (undated; text dates from about 1975–76).
Eduardo S. Lichauco to the Board of Directors, Bank of the Philippine Islands, resignation letter, 12 March 1975.
Eduardo S. Lichauco to Enrique Zobel, resignation letter, 16 March 1976.
Enrique Zobel to Eduardo S. Lichauco, letter, 19 March 1976.
Eduardo S. Lichauco to SEC Chairman Manuel Abello, letter, 3 January 1983.
San Miguel Corporation director's fee receipts, 1983.
Hari Bedi, "The Problem With Poaching," Asiaweek, 16 February 1990, p. 72.
Fernando del Mundo, "Revolt rocks San Miguel boardroom," UPI, 18 February 1983.
Presidential Decree No. 117, "Facilitating Bank Mergers or Consolidations," 29 January 1973.
Sandy Lichauco, "The 43-Year-Old Receipt: A 1983 Corporate 'Food Fight'," NineteenKopongKopong.
Sandy Lichauco, "P.O. Box 259: The Prequel Was in the Mailbox," NineteenKopongKopong.


































Comments